For decades, "shareholder value" has been touted as the guiding star of business strategy. The idea, championed by economists like Milton Friedman, suggests that companies exist primarily to maximize returns for their shareholders. On the surface, this approach seems logical—after all, shareholders invest their capital, so their interests should be prioritized. But this line of thinking, when taken to extremes, has created unintended consequences that ripple through organizations and society as a whole.
The problem with shareholder thinking is that it narrows focus. It prioritizes quarterly results over long-term growth, stock prices over culture, and short-term profits over people. In doing so, it fosters a mindset that often sacrifices the very elements that build sustainable, thriving companies. People.
The Hidden Costs of Shareholder-Centric Thinking
- Erosion of Company Culture A strong organizational culture is the foundation for innovation, collaboration, and resilience. However, when shareholder value dominates the conversation, investments in culture can take a backseat. Leadership often cuts back on initiatives that nurture employees' growth or enhance workplace satisfaction, viewing them as "nonessential." Over time, this erodes trust, engagement, and morale.
- Undermining Long-Term Vision Shareholder thinking emphasizes immediate results. Companies chasing quarterly earnings targets may neglect long-term opportunities that require patience and investment. This short-termism stifles innovation, discourages risk-taking, and ultimately leaves companies ill-equipped to adapt to market changes.
- Dehumanizing the Workforce When businesses focus solely on the bottom line, people become numbers—line items on a balance sheet to be reduced or optimized. Layoffs, wage stagnation, and burnout are justified as necessary evils to meet financial targets. Yet, this approach ignores the fact that a company's greatest asset is its people.
- Harming Communities and Society Shareholder primacy often leads to decisions that prioritize profit over the well-being of communities. From environmental degradation to exploitative labor practices, the pursuit of profit can leave lasting harm. Such actions may yield financial returns in the short term, but they erode public trust and create long-term reputational risks.
A Better Way Forward: Stakeholder Thinking
The alternative to shareholder thinking is stakeholder thinking, a mindset that considers the interests of all parties impacted by a company’s actions: employees, customers, communities, and shareholders alike. Stakeholder-oriented companies recognize that long-term success is built on creating value for everyone involved, not just those who hold stock.
- Focusing on People and Culture Investing in employees and fostering a strong, inclusive culture pays dividends in the form of higher engagement, innovation, and retention. Companies like Patagonia and Salesforce are celebrated not just for their financial success but for their commitment to culture and purpose.
- Building for the Long Term Shifting away from the pressures of quarterly earnings enables companies to focus on sustainable growth and innovation. Amazon, for example, has often traded short-term profits for long-term market dominance.
- Restoring Trust When businesses operate with integrity and consider their broader impact, they strengthen relationships with customers, employees, and communities. This trust creates a virtuous cycle of loyalty and support that fuels sustainable growth.
Rethinking Success
Reimagining corporate priorities isn’t just the right thing to do—it’s the smart thing to do. Companies that adopt a stakeholder approach consistently outperform those focused solely on shareholders. Studies have shown that businesses prioritizing Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors see better financial performance over time.
It’s time for leaders to move beyond the outdated dogma of shareholder primacy. By focusing on people, culture, and long-term value creation, businesses can drive sustainable success that benefits everyone involved—not just the investors.
Let’s stop asking, “How much value can we extract for shareholders?” and start asking, “How can we create value for everyone?”
That’s a question worth answering.
- John
#ValueOfPeople#PeopleOverProfit#WeighTheValue#HumanCenteredDesign#EconomicBalance#LeadershipMatters#SocialImpact#ImpactOverIncome#SustainableBusiness#FutureOfWork